This page as a pdf file
Insulin pump evaluation
Mike Jensen, who lives in New Zealand, discusses his experience of using an insulin pump for a trial period of three weeks
I experienced a significantly better quality of sleep overnight and woke feeling more refreshed and ready for the day. Usually (under MDI) I would wake feeling tired and unrefreshed and would struggle to get out of bed and into the day. I experienced significantly more energy to start the day with.
Additionally, it was a relief to not be tied to 7:30am and 9:30pm Lente injections. Having to have these injections means not being able to go to bed early or sleep-in in the morning. Being able to enjoy flexible (and restful) sleep was heavenly!
Years of intensive therapy have given me good BG control but have resulted in a steady weight gain. Weight gain associated with good glycemic control is a well-known phenomenon of course. I have found it to be impossible to keep my weight down in conjunction with good glycemic control and a balance of exercise. The pump enabled me to manage my weight really well using the proven weight management scenarios possible with insulin pumping. During the three weeks on the pump I steadily lost weight (approximately 2kg) but since going back on MDI have put this back on! Carrying this excess weight is unlikely to help my long-term prognosis.
My dawn phenomenon continues to be aggressive. During setting of the pump basal rate I was able to quantify exactly how intense it is (the overnight basal rate varies between 0.8 and 1.4 units/hour whereas between 6am and 9am the required basal rate was 3.0 units/hour).
Trying to closely match my dawn requirements with MDI has been impossible. The best I can do is to tune the bedtime Lente by increasing/decreasing the dose to try and achieve acceptable fasting BGs. However, I am indeed lucky if I can actually obtain a good BG. My fasting BG is typically on the high side and to make matters worse the variability of these fasting BGs is confounding. I loved how I could match my requirements much more precisely using the pump and the results were excellent.
Flexibility and Lifestyle
I like to lead a varied and flexible life. It's who I am. For me this includes variable eating, sleeping, leisure, and exercise. For the first time in my life I could say that the pump offered the possibility of getting close to the degree of flexibility and lifestyle that I need. Under MDI I am simply unable to achieve this.
Feeling Better and Stability
On the pump I "felt better" than on MDI. I can best describe this as feeling less fragile, more relaxed, more confident and in control, and with a better peace of mind. This was noticed by other people who recognised the difference in me and gave favourable comments back to me. I felt "in control" and was able to relax about my diabetes and to finally give it a less dominant role in my life.
Finally I could relax knowing my BGs were stable and predictable. Under MDI I can never be confident of stability, the BGs always seemed to be going somewhere.
Overall I experienced a significant boost in my energy levels when compared to living with MDI. I would rate this boost as quite significant. I certainly felt better in the morning after a good night's sleep, and I was far less prone to having waves of sleep roll over me after lunch.
I believe that as I diabetic with a demanding control scenario and with particular lifestyle requirements I am well placed to make some general comments.
A quality of life has been lost to diabetes. Indeed, I thought my world was crumbling when I was diagnosed in 1984 at the age of 25. Suddenly the "best" years became "not the best" years. I was consumed by confusion, irritability, fluctuating BGs and weariness and these are definitely highly significant issues for me to this day. I struggled to manage my care and was given a mixture of very good and very indifferent advice from my medical support personnel around the country. As far as I could see, as long as I did not show up in Accident and Emergency I was doing fine. I believe that as I appeared to medical staff to be well motivated, articulate, cooperative, and intelligent, that I conveyed a false picture that I was "OK". I also believe that my understanding of diabetes was inadequate and that I felt unable to ask for what I really needed from the medical system (thankfully this is no longer the case). Note that much trial and error has resulted in the most stable MDI regimen that I have ever experienced (a combination of twice daily Lente for basal and Humalog for bolus) and that this regimen was chosen by myself and tuned largely by myself).
Clearly though, I am less than "OK". Conventional therapy using MDI has not really worked well for me and I am totally convinced that my quality of life is only "average". I am increasingly weary and struggling to get by. My reality of living with "difficult" diabetes is extremely unpleasant and anything to assist the management of my condition would be received with open arms. Pump therapy, I believe, offers the real promise that this can be changed forever for me.
I believe that the decision to pump should not be based too strongly on the HbA1c as this doesn't take into account the factors I have discussed above. Note that it's only a general indicator and there are many things to be considered in a diabetic's overall quality of life. As a diabetic with a HbA1c of 6% I have to say that it's not all that significant. The question for me is not only how good my HbA1c is but how I am doing as a person overall. I feel strongly that I am not doing terribly well in a "total person" sense. Many doctors will say that improving my already good control by actively managing it won't help reduce the risk of complications but this really isn't the point. I know that my BG needs to be stable and my life flexible and enjoyable in order for me to be a "well person". I felt that with the pump there was a certainty of hope towards achieving this.
Why I Am I Not Going to Go On the Pump?
Well, it's a cost thing, pure and simple. I cannot afford to fund both the initial purchase and the ongoing cost of consumables.
I would like to see the health system assisting diabetics to go on pump therapy. Clearly there are diabetics who have terrible control and who are immediate candidates for pump therapy. Clearly there are also diabetics, such as myself, who have issues of quality of life and additionally who are motivated to achieve a superior standard of health care for themselves. Both categories surely are deserving of both clinical and financial assistance to enable pump therapy to become an option.
I have to say without reservation though that I would love to be part of and to support the development of a pump program in Otago. I look forward to the time when conditions for a pump program are favourable. I believe that as an articulate person with a scientific background I am well able to help support and develop such an initiative.
Graphs from Bayer Winglucofacts
CSII - Summary Profile
CSII - Glucose Trend Profile:
CSII - Modal Day Profile:
MDI - Summary Profile:
MDI - Glucose Trend Profile:
MDI - Modal Day Profile:
Last updated: November 1999
On 15 Jan 2006 Roy Molyneux wrote:
I have been using the Accu Check Spirit for 11 weeks now after being on MDI for 42 years. As many have commented before me, it gives you more flexability to suit your own lifestyle. The diabetes rule book was ripped up and thrown out the window from day 1! If you have the commitment to change and manage, intensly, our condition, then go for it.
On 30 Jan 2005 Brad Smith wrote:
With having diabetes for 10 years now, I have constantly changed regimes, doses, insulin types & unpredictable BG's. I am soon going onto the pump to help me sort this out & make my life 'worth living' as I'm constantly changing moods, attitudes & I am getting less energetic every day. (I've not been to the gym for 2wks now!!) I hope the pump will change all this just by settling my BG's & so I can lead a normal life for once in 10 years!!
On 30 Mar 2004 Ian Wilson wrote:
Hello to all. Reading this, I have just got internet and find it amazing how other people feel on their day to day insulin and blood sugar levels. I myself am on insulin 4x a day (3x NovoRapid 1x glargine). Since my change to this in Oct, Nov last year I find no great improvement in control and generally feel ill all the time, no energy, mood swings, full of aches and pains, although doctors feel generally happy with things it doesnt help me from day to day.
I have a number of complications now and every year they just get worse. I have heard that now the insulin pump is on NHS and from what I've heard about it seems to be a way through for me and probably many diabetics. With no disrespect to doctors, they just feel happy to increase-decrease insulin with no improved results. I either go hyper or hypo? Please help: what do you do?
On 7 May 2002 Selena Vincin wrote:
Mike, I can't tell from the website how old your post is re: a three week trial of an insulin pump. So I apologize if it's really old news.
We live in the Hawkes Bay, and have been told that there is ONE other pumper in this entire region. My husband is on week three of a six-week trial period. He was forced to leave work and go on sickness benefit due to increasing brittleness and mounting complications (and a job that was really not suitable in the first place, but was all he could get).
Since he is on the benefit now, we are dealing with WINZ as well as the health board in our appeals for funding for the pump. We have no private insurance.
Thus far, no one will pony up the cash. We *may* be able to extend our mortgage, or our credit limit in order to cover the initial outlay, but those possibilities are remote, would put us in serious financial straits, and would leave us gasping to meet ongoing costs.
I was wondering if you have found any solution to the funding problem yourself?
Sincerely (and hopefully)
On 10 Jul 2001 Leslie wrote:
Mike - I felt like I was going around a road bend FAST as I read your story. I have been there - for 31 years, through the birth of 2 children and through all the - that life portends. I just went on a pump because of unmanageable dawn effect morning blood sugars and am already noticing a difference in control and quality of life. The cost has deterred me until now - no coverage at all. I hope you find a way to cover the cost - I know how unspeakably difficult life can be controlling this disease day by day, despite good A1c's. Godsped, Mike.
On 27 Apr 2001 Allan Bennett wrote:
I found your report very informative with some useful information. Your medical experiences are similar to mine and I've been a type 1 for 46 years.
My BGs vary between 1.5 and 22 mmol/l and I test 7/8 times a day with 4 shots of humalog. I don't believe this control is 'OK'.
I too have difficulty with funding and when I approached my GP she said I was managing 'OK' and so didn't need a pump. My diabetic consultant took a similar approach but said he would 'put me on the list'. I could feel another year or so slipping by and asked if I found the capital cost, would the clinic fund the monthly running costs.
He agreed to this scenario and I shall start on the punp at the end of May '01. I've chosen the 508 which, in the UK, will cost me £2180. I'll let the pumpers group know how it goes.